What Is The Real Reason Culture Change Fails?
Before we start here, if you haven’t grabbed the free guide on Running Better 1:1s, it is waiting for you. Get it here!
Every company says they want to “change their culture.”
What they really mean is:
- New office layout
- New values on a slide
- Maybe a few workshops
Then they look around and wonder why nothing actually changed.
The reason is simple. They are fixing what they can see. But culture lives in what they cannot see.
That is exactly what Edgar Schein explained with his Organizational Culture Model. And most people still get it wrong.
Let’s talk about why.
The Three Layers of Culture (And Where the Mistakes Begin)
Edgar Schein’s model breaks culture into three levels:
1. Artifacts
The visible stuff. Furniture. Dress code. Communication tools. Mission statements. Easy to observe. Easy to copy.
But also, easy to misunderstand.
A modern office design doesn’t promote collaboration.
Casual dress doesn’t provide psychological safety.
These are just signals — not guarantees.
2. Espoused Values
These are the beliefs people say they hold.
“We value innovation.”
“We promote transparency.”
They look great on LinkedIn.
But saying a value means nothing if behaviors do not match.
The real test is what happens when values meet reality.
For example, do people get rewarded for experimenting?
Or punished when they fail?
3. Underlying Assumptions
This is where the real culture exists. Invisible beliefs. Deep habits.
The things nobody writes down, but everyone follows.
“Working late shows commitment.”
“Leaders should never be questioned.”
“Bad news stays hidden.”
Nobody teaches these in onboarding.
But people learn them fast.
And once these assumptions are set, they shape everything.
Decision-making. Feedback. Collaboration. Trust.
Why Most Culture Programs Fail (And Keep Failing)
The typical culture change effort stays at the surface.
- New office aesthetics
- Updated vision statements
- Motivational events
All good for photo ops. Useless for real behavior change.
Because the hard work happens below the surface. At the assumption level. And most leaders avoid that, for two reasons:
It’s uncomfortable.
Challenging assumptions means admitting past mistakes.
It means rethinking how leaders act, not just how they communicate.
It’s slow and messy.
Real culture change requires time, trust, and visible behavior shifts.
There are no quick wins. And no shortcuts.
Real Culture Is Revealed Under Pressure
If you want to see a company’s true culture, watch what happens when things go wrong.
- How does the team handle a failed project?
- What happens when an employee challenges a decision?
- How are mistakes discussed — openly or quietly buried?
These moments reveal the actual assumptions driving behavior.
No values slide will protect you here.
Culture is what people do when nobody is watching.
That is where change must start.
How to Approach Culture Change the Right Way
Here is a more honest approach, based on Schein’s model:
Stop obsessing over surface-level artifacts.
A new office design won’t fix trust issues.
Test your values with real behavior.
If “innovation” is a value, track how failure is treated.
Bring hidden assumptions to light.
Ask your team: “What unspoken rules do we follow here?”
The answers will surprise you.
Change what leaders do, not what they say.
Culture follows behavior. Always.
Why This Still Matters Today
Even with all the research, people still treat culture like a communication problem.
In reality, it is a systems problem.
Culture emerges from repeated behaviors, shaped by invisible beliefs.
Schein’s model is useful because it forces us to look below the surface.
It is not complicated. But it requires courage. And patience.
If you are serious about changing culture, stop rearranging the furniture.
Start challenging the assumptions that actually drive what people do.
Source: MIT Sloan Management Review
Enjoyed this post? If this helped or inspired you, consider supporting the writing process: Buy me a coffee
If this helped, you’ll love Decoding Digital Leadership. A weekly newsletter with strategies, reflections, and tools for growing as a leader in the world of technology.
Join today, and you can get the free guide: 1:1 Toolkit for New Leaders
